Jul 29 2007
Rear Naked Ramblings – Should It Be Shogun vs. Liddell Instead?
News and notes from around the MMA world …
- Sam Caplan tries to rank the top 10 biggest underacheivers in MMA today. People might be talking about that one.
- In Kevin Iole’s mailbag, he talks about how he disagrees with the choice of Chuck Liddell’s next opponent. I’ll have more on that below.
- ShoXC, which is the minor leagues of sorts for Elite XC, had their first show last night and here’s the report from F4Wonline.com.
- Pro Elite buys into UK’s Cage Rage according to The Fight Network.
- After having his victory in Pride over Takanori Gomi taken away after he tested positive for marijuana, Nick Diaz is back.
Talking Points
Kevin Iole from Yahoo! Sports says:
No disrespect meant to the “Dean of Mean” here because I like him as a fighter and he’s a good guy, but I would rather have seen Liddell fight Shogun Rua on the Sept. 22 show. Rua fought in Pride before coming to the UFC and White wants to expose him to the UFC audience before putting him in a big event like that. But I think enough fans know Rua and would have gotten excited by a Liddell-Rua main event that it could have, and should have, been made.
Iole thinks that Dana White should put together the dream match between Shogun Rua and Chuck Liddell when probably 95% of the audience doesn’t know Rua. Because it’s a sport and you can’t fix the outcomes, match making becomes more about putting people in the octagon together with hopes of certain outcomes. But you can’t really predict the outcomes as easily as in the past. Upsets have been the story in the UFC specifically this year. Georges St. Pierre was well on his way to probably the biggest pay day of his career if he could defeat Matt Serra. That victory would’ve set up a title rematch (and rubber match in their series) with Matt Hughes. The only problem with the scenario was Serra. Serra shocked the MMA world with a knockout of St. Pierre, and now he gets to face Hughes and it’s not as big of a fight.
The best thing for the UFC is to have Liddell beat Jardine and Shogun Rua beat Forrest Griffin. That could set up a match with Chuck Liddell and Wanderlei Silva and you’d probably give Shogun one more fight. And then both guys would win and face off in the dream match that we all want to see. But that’s two fights each that need to end up with Liddell and Rua victorious, in order to put together their match in the way it would make the most money. However, if you were to put Shogun in there with Liddell today, without his introduction into UFC, it wouldn’t do good business. But then again, if either he or Liddell loses before finally facing off, it probably doesn’t do great business either.
I think Dana White and company are making the right decision though. As long as Shogun wins, he’ll put himself into big matches even if Liddell doesn’t. And if he doesn’t, then he probably doesn’t deserve to be in that spot anyway. But I don’t think he will. He’s far too good.